Yep, you read that right. To find out what place pasta can hold in a healthy diet, we called in Carolyn Brown , RD, a nutritionist at the private practice Food Trainers in New York City, to get to the bottom line of is pasta bad for you, once and for all.
First things first: pasta is packed with carbohydrates. Just one cup of cooked spaghetti delivers 42 grams of carbs, about a sixth of one's recommended daily carb intake on a 2,calorie diet. That may not sound like much, but it bears noting that almost no one ever eats just one cup of pasta at a time.
Order spaghetti Bolognese at a restaurant, and you're likely to eat at least two to three servings of pasta in one sitting. What's more, is that calories add up fast when we eat pasta. Just one cup of cooked pasta contains about calories. Fresh pasta is typically mixed, cooked and eaten immediately, while dried pasta is prepared and stored for a later time. Because it contains eggs and additional water, fresh pasta is more tender than dried pasta and takes about half the time to cook.
Conversely, dried pasta is made from finely ground semolina flour, water and sometimes salt. Once mixed into a paste, the dough is pushed through moulds and cut into the wide variety of pasta shapes we know and love.
Unlike fresh pasta, this pasta is dried at a low temperature for several days until all the moisture has evaporated allowing it to be stored in the pantry almost indefinitely. Nutritionally speaking there is a very little difference between fresh and dried pasta given the ingredients used to make them are so similar. The difference between whole-grain pasta and white pasta or refined pasta is simply that the flour used to make whole grain pasta contained the entire grain bran, germ and endosperm , while the flour used to make white pasta only contained the endosperm.
A grain of wheat contains three edible parts: the bran, the germ and the endosperm. When ground into flour, grains are broken down into tiny pieces and the bran, germ and endosperm are separated in the process.
From here, these different parts can be separated, or combined, to make different types of flour , including whole wheat flour and white flour.
Nutritionally speaking, whole grain pasta will contain slightly more nutrients and fibre, given it still contains the bran and the endosperm, however, it can also contain more anti-nutrients found in the bran and germ making it more difficult for some people to digest. Although often touted as nutritionally superior, whole grain pasta is not necessarily a healthier option than white pasta and, regardless of which you chose to eat, you should always read the label and opt for versions with minimal ingredients and limited additives and preservatives.
For those who can not consume wheat or gluten for allergy, intolerance or dietary reasons pasta alternatives are a great way to enjoy a noodle dish, however, if you looking to pasta alternatives thinking they are superior options you are misguided.
Fresh pasta only lasts a day or two and is usually found in the chilled section of supermarkets. Dried pasta is made from semolina, which is made from grinding the heart of durum wheat, and water. It is then made into a paste and moulded into different shapes, such as shells or tubes, and left to dry at a low temperature for several days until all the moisture has evaporated and it dries hard, allowing it to be stored for a longer period. Pasta is primarily a carbohydrate, but it also contains a good amount of fibre and some protein.
Wholemeal pasta contains almost twice as much fibre as white pasta, with just one g serving providing about a third of the total recommended daily allowance of fibre for adults. Pasta has a good mineral content including calcium, magnesium, iron and zinc, as well as B vitamins. According to scientist Dr Denise Robertson , from the University of Surrey, cooked-then-cooled pasta acts more like fibre in your body. This creates a smaller glucose spike resulting in better blood sugar control , helps to feed the good bacteria in your gut and also means that you absorb fewer calories from the same quantity of pasta.
The NHS recommends that one third of our diet should be made up of starchy foods such as pasta, and that the higher-fibre wholemeal varieties are the healthier option.
As a guide, about g is a good-sized portion — about two large handfuls. Creamy or cheese-based sauces can add significantly to the fat, salt and calorie content of the dish, so these should be eaten as an occasional treat rather than as an everyday option. Wholewheat pasta is by far the best pasta option, thanks to its high fibre content — this will help to fill you up for longer, support digestive health and lower the risk of heart disease, stroke and type 2 diabetes.
The study, which was published in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention, and Health, sought to determine if there is a link between eating pasta and the long-term risk of type 2 diabetes , atherosclerotic cardiovascular diseases ASCVD , and stroke. Among the 84, postmenopausal women in the study, women who ate the most pasta had a reduced risk for ASCVD and stroke compared to the women who at less pasta.
The highest intake of pasta consumed was a little over three servings of pasta a week. The lowest was just under a half-serving of pasta a week. The researchers found no significant increase in diabetes risk in the women who included pasta in their diet. They did note, however, that when the women replaced another starchy meal—like fried potato or white bread—with pasta, it could decrease their risk of diabetes.
When the participants replaced fried potatoes with a pasta meal, it decreased their risk of stroke, ASCVD, and diabetes. When they replaced white bread with pasta, it reduced their risk of ASCVD and stroke but did not make much difference to their diabetes risk. One of the main limitations of the study is that only included postmenopausal women, which limits how applicable the results are. Using a food frequency questionnaire is not always a reliable way to collect data.
In this study, it could have limited the researchers' ability to obtain details that may have affected the results—for example, the proportion of pasta in relation to the participant's entire meal.
We need carbs because they give our bodies energy, but the kind of carbohydrates that we include in our diets affects how beneficial they are to us. Research shows that we typically get more health benefits from choosing carbs with a low glycemic load—meaning that they do not cause our blood sugar to rise as high as foods with a higher glycemic load.
The recent BMJ study shows pasta has a lower glycaemic index GI and glycaemic load GL than other major sources of carbohydrates given the same amount. Additionally, a study published in Frontiers in Nutrition found that pasta consumption is associated with better diet quality and better nutrient intakes compared to diets that do not include pasta. Pasta may offer health benefits, but because it's a carbohydrate, you want to be mindful of not consuming it in excess of what your body needs.
0コメント